+12 votes
6.1k views
in Technology by (220 points)

Hi, I'm Noah, a 9-year-old boy living in Charlotte, NC. I am here because my parents will not let me get a phone. Even offering to pay for it 100%, they refuse to let me. I still do not know why. I've even asked for a literal Nokia 3310. They still say no. I use my computer an offal lot. That's because: I don't have an iPad. I don't have an iPod. I am stuck to all of the 2-year-old Elmo apps, and that rubbish. I had to reset my laptop even to open Microsoft Edge. I have asked them if I can use it with max restrictions. THEY STILL SAY NO. I also explained that it would be used for emergencies only, and they still refuse. Even if it's a car crash with my parents, they still will say no. Even if our school is on lockdown! STILL NO. I try and work myself down to a smartwatch. Still don't get anything with cellular connectivity. By now, they're saying, "Shut it, little #####!" This is getting more annoying than needed. I ask if we can start a hand-me-down process. Still no. And so now, this is getting overwhelming. I think, "why don't I just give up on this dumb process.." I have begged day and night for a phone. Even if it is one million years old. (that was a hyperbally sarcastic phrase.) I still am begging, I have given them a million reasons. "Mom, I won't do ...bad stuff, I'll use it in emergencies if at school, etc." It's still a no. They don't give a "fish." Thus I am much more angry than needed, due to not having one, even after 2 years straight of begging for one. I am not trying to be greedy or anything, but, we could at least work out a smartwatch deal. So I talk back to my mother. Me: "Mom, if you are able to spend £1,788 on your iPhone 13 Pro Max, then it mustn't be an issue for me to get a flippin'  £22 watch." 

Mom: "How dare you talk back to me! Now you don't get your computer until you get your driver's license."

Me: "Pardon me?"

Mom: (repeats herself)

Me: "Ohh... I get the moral now! Being a kid sucks!"

Mom: "No, that's not what I was trying to say-"

Me: "Act like it!"

And that's how it all went.

by (15.6k points)
Hopefully this will help you feel better, because I'm 11 and don't have a phone!!!
by
Hey I didn't get my phone until I was in 8th but it was a flip phone and now 16 I have a Samsung A12 and it's the best you have to give it time
by (390 points)
Same with me i'm 13 and still only have a flip phone nokia that my parents control !!!!!!!!!!
by
bro SAME. i am turning 13 really soon and have 2 big trips to go to and i dont have a computer, phone, even a smartwatch. its ok, we understand you. dont feel bad! :)
by (6.3k points)
Look, I don't want to be mean or anything so hear me out.

I am better at tech than both my parents combined. Oh, what makes that even better is the fact that my mum runs customers and digital in the water company that provides to the entire south west of England. So yh, not to boast but I'm good at tech. So looking at this evidence I didn't get my first iPad till I was 9 and that was a school one so it doesn't really count cause I couldn't do anything  except you school work. I got my first proper iPad that I could do stuff on when I was ten and even then a lot of things like YouTube and social media where banned. Now I am twelve I got my first phone for Christmas after begging for years. I have wanted a phone since I was 5 because I'm just really passionate about tech.

My response to every time my mum said no was, 'can we talk about it'. We made a plan for all my tech and when I'd get it and she even allowed me to choose which phone. I got the Samsung A14 because she said I had to save half if I didn't want to get her old phone and yh, that's it. Another thing I'd recommend is to talk to your friends. I'm just saying. If 2 people in your class have a phone because their parents have divorced and their mum/dad live really far away than they have a phone for a specific purpose. If someone in your class has a phone because they have a medical problem than think of how it can help them. If someone in your class has to walk 15 mins to get home everyday when it gets dark than a phone is really just a good reassurance to their parents. Another thing is don't exagerate. I exaggerated with ear piercings and it turns out that my mum was going to get my ears pierced that summer but because I lied/all my friends lied about EVERYONE getting their ears pierced again, I got set back.

Weigh up the pros and cons like pick up or safety or an emergency. Make sure you think about how it benefits them as well as making sure it benefits you. But also don't think to heavily about how it benefits them because then they will just think you are skating over the bad parts. So yh, that is my advice for pursueding parents and also, I'm going to say this now. MORE KIDS IN YOUR CLASS DONT HAVE A PHONE THAN HAVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Anyone who has a phone is going to want to show it of so it often feels like more people have a phone than actually have. It's quite annoying actually.

So yh, hope you listened

Girl online going offline

Ps.sorry my comment is so long
by
bro. just be a kid. go outside, play on the device you used to ask this question, bake, read, hang out with your friends/family, watch a movie or a show or something, play video games, play board games, etc. don’t worry about what people think of you. stay a kid for as long as you can, and try to make friends.

all because nobody gets a second chance to make new old friends. :) -luke bryan
by
your literally a child and your begging for a phone first you need to grow up into your teenager years and do nice things for your parents then mabye they would allow you. like what the heck your all kids and your worried about getting a phone. a phone is not all that you should just live your life live your childhood then start worrying when you are actually in the outside world. honestly you all need to grow up.
by (18.1k points)
boiiiii i have three phone wait no... four lol

and they are all working!!!
by
at least I have a dad
by
I feel kids should get phones when they become teenagers. When I was around 13, I used to explore a lot with my friends and my parents constantly texted me on my phone to check in on me and make sure I was ok. The phone helped my parents with their anxiety.
by

same! im 12 and my parents are as toxic af they threaten and abuse me every day! one time, my parents beat me up so hard i bled so much! plus, i need the phone for literal school and they still dont let me! they also pretended to be me bc i gave my group members my moms phone number and she pretended to be me in the group chat! like //big-eyes//! i  honestly just want to run away from home by this point.

by
Hey, I'm probably just like you..I keep asking for a phone and I still won't get one and I've been at this for years. But I've realized that it's ok to not have one. Even though everyone keeps showing off their iPhone 15s and their literally 13! ? But at least I have a friend that can help and build me up, like a true friend would. So now I know that phones can't even come close to match up to what really matters.

P.S my friend dosent have a phone either
by
Bro, All my friends have phones and i'm FREAKIN 12 ! YOUR 9. I don't even have a phone yet!
by
Its okay buddy. Im 17 and my parents won't let me buy a phone. Just be a kid as long as you can.
by
Yeah! Im 12 and the only kid in my class that doesn't have a phone!

PS- I only get to play games for 1 hour on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays and only at four O'clock. My parents are dumb.
by
I didn’t get a phone until I was 13. I saved up to buy it, and I bought an IPhone XR. It’s the best for me rn. Start your own savings by asking your parents to sponsor a cashapp for you. Do chores and help out in return for money. Put it into your savings on cashapp and then save it for when your parents let you buy a phone.
by
Man you don’t even know bro
by (6.3k points)
Also, cool Syd? I love how you presume that a) it's always the dad that leaves and b) that just because parents are divorced you can't see both. My parents have been divorced since I was 7, they are really good friends and I see my dad whenever I want

It does help that my dad found an apartment near where my mum lives but just please don't assume that because I said if their parents are divorced it means that one of the parents walked put

Girl online going offline
by
I have rly strict Asian parents who wont allow any screen time whatsoever (on school days) Even after I finish my hw! Plus I don't have an apple watch or phone and I'm not getting either until I'm in 9th grade (I'm in 6th at the moment). I don't know what to do abt the situation.

Also Idk if its just me but its so aggravating seeing kids younger than you who already have a phone!
by
Umm...They make you bleed? yk that's illegal right? Child abuse? Can someone get the cops for this girls?
by
WHAT? 17? BRO thats messed up
by
I'm 17 and still don't have my first phone
by
Same I’m 12 and this keeps happening. I even asked for an Apple Watch Series 6 and they still say no! If it makes you feel better, there are other people in your shoes.
by
Hi I actually have the same problem with my parents. But to be fair because of not having a phone I lashed out and figured my way into YouTube even with restrictions. But know I now why the don’t won’t me to see it. Despite being angry I realized that the reason they don’t want me exposed to that content is because they love me and they know the hidden dangers that a 11 year old can’t see. I quote my dad “ sometimes kids just can’t always see the bigger picture and that is what parents are for”. At first I didn’t know what he meant then when I looked at the YouTube stuff I actually saw content that traumatized me. Like I was already scared of bugs but I was getting over it then I saw a video and I was so scared that I still haven’t gotten over that fear. So just remember parents love you and you know that because they have always loved you even when you were just in a stomach they have always loved you and always will. And when their methods may seem rude it is all just to keep you safe. :)
by
im 16 and still dont have a phone. I've been left by friends at malls and other places with no possible way of contacting parents. it just feels unsafe to go anywhere without a phone at this point. i feel a bad person could see I don't have a phone and take advantage of that situation since they know I cannot get any help. i don't know how I'm going to even get a drivers license or start driving since I do not want to drive without a phone in case of emergency. i cannot imagine myself getting a job either since a lot of jobs require you to get an app of theirs or text your boss. I've had a lot of difficulties with school as well since we have had numerous assignments where we have needed a phone. sometimes we even have resources such as an online textbook and aren't provided with a real textbook and the only way to get the online textbook is by scanning a QR code. i think it is starting to get ridiculous and my mom is just being stubborn and holding onto her own beliefs. i used to have a phone, but it has been over a year. it made sense for me to not have a phone for a year due to my actions, however, I have learned very well since then and she knows this. i also can't imagine driving without being able to use a GPS or have that immediate safety device on me. she assumes I will text and drive however I am not like your average teenager even though I was a phone addict. i still know right from wrong and am able to control myself when genuinely needed. if I really wanted to talk to someone while driving, I could just call them and focus on the road. I've encountered many issues as well such as people giving me trouble at the gym I go to for not having the app and I explained that I don't have a phone and they held me from going for awhile and gave me a hard time. I've lost many friends as well since it can be difficult to maintain contact with me and I have 0 social life now. the friends I have had were too bothered by me using their phone to text my parents and all the difficulties they had to go through just to send me something. in this day and age we are involving, near everyone has a phone. we use ATMs which are digital and credit  cards which are also used digitally.  our world is evolving and at this point it feels that I am deprived of a basic freedom. i haven't left the house in a long time since if I am with a friend they might have to leave early and I am left alone. i am also scared of leaving the house without a phone as I don't know what could happen to me. i tend to draw in weird people for some reason and I know this. I've encountered many strange reactions in real life even at just a mall. i cannot imagine if I was left alone with an odd person and I had no way of contacting anyone. once even I was at my cousins party and there was a father there who was following me around and kept talking to me and flirting with me and was being very creepy. i could not contact my parents or anything and I felt very stressed due to this. many people I have told about my parents not letting me get a phone to think that my parents don't care about me or are crazy. I've mentioned everything that I have just mentioned to my parents but they still don't budge. my parents find every excuse in the book. i am unable to even submit any math homework and have had many troubles with grades due to this. I have good grades now, but every time I get zeros and have to have long talks with teachers for them to give me full points. each time I get a new teacher I have to explain my situation as well and they all look at me a bit strangely. this was fastly typed and sort of a rant so due to that this was not written very well, just to let everyone get an idea of it. I forgot to add but I also have a laptop and I can do a lot of things that a phone can do except use messages or take it places so it does not make sense.
by
Yea my parents are the same. I’m 11 years old and I’m going into 6th grade in September. I help with chores around the house and I got good grades for the whole school year and it’s still a straight up no. I give them so many mature reasons for one and still no. I don’t care if I get a Samsung galaxy S2 or the first telephone from 1876. I’ve been asking for almost a year now. One time I actually had a phone it was an iPhone 8 but then my Dad got a call from his old business saying that they needed the phone back and then he needed to bring back the phone so yeah that’s it.
by
True bro I’m in 10 and my mom has a new phone but she still won’t give me her old one
by
You guys are way too young, not the 16-year-old but the comments. You should have a phone at grade 8. Not any younger in some countries. It is even illegal. Don't say you can relate when the truth is you're just a spoiled brat.
by
IT LITTERALLY IS SO AGRIVATING SEEING EVERYONE IN YOUR ENTIRE

CLASS HAS A PHONE I HAVE BEGED MY PARENTS FOR A PHONE FOR YEARS AND I LITTERALLLY AM 9 AND THEY STILL WONT LET ME EVERY

TIME I GET INTO A NEW HIGHER GRADE THE MORE THE MAJORITY OF MY CLASS HAS A PHONE I HAVE NONE OF MY OWN DEVICES I USE MY MOM'S COMPUTER
by
I feel the same. I'm literally 13 and all my friends are like can I have your number and I'm like you can have my moms that I can text you on. Some of them are ok with it some are like never mind. All my friends come up to me and say look I have a phone. Why! Its not their fault I don't have a phone but still it makes me think about wanting a phone even more.
by
+1
My mom said that i can get a flip phone if i get a year of full a or b I'm now in middle school and my friends don't like to have moms numbers on their phone
by
I'm 13 years old and I have a phone currently but SO MANY RESTRICTIONS. I'm in 8th grade and everyone had phones and TikTok and Snapchat and Instagram and all that stuff but my parents wont let me have any of those apps and take my phone randomly to go through it. Trust me, you don't want a phone right now, especially if it is heavily monitored. I'm not tryna be some weird old grandma that's lying about the perks of something but its true. My phone and all the monitoring and stuff that happens with it is the cause of my anxiety. I tried buying an Iphone behind my moms back so I wasn't monitored and I got even more restrictions which I didn't know was possible. I cant have it in my room EVER unless it is in a timed lock box with no way to open until the timer goes off that goes up to 90 hours. Anyways I'm going off topic but the point is that my phone has honestly caused addiction to it, anxiety, depression, body dysmorphia, and an awful relationship with my parents. Overall it's really not worth it. Sorry I doubt u will read all this and the grammar sucks ik. Hope this helps you feel better if you still don't have a phone tho.
by
+1
Buddy if your nine and your complaining about not having a phone.. YOU GUYS ARE SO SPOILED!! I'm almost 13 and I still don't have a phone! My parents took away my SAMSUNG TAB A (I have used it since I was 8, it has screen cracks) and they hid it somewhere they won't give me and electronics until 5:30 and only 30 mins
by
This is to StrangerThingsFan:

Gurl don't tell people that its ur moms number. Js say its ur ipad or smth. That's what I do when people ask for my number.
by
+1
I am 13 about to be 14 and I'm still asking for a phone. Its so annoying the little 6th graders have them and im in 8th grade rn. my mom got the iPhone 16 plus today and she still won't let me have her old raggedy rusty iPhone 11. It's actually so annoying she keeps yapping about how I need to learn more, but I literally would get extra credit in some classes for putting my phone on the phone collector thing in school. I feel like I deserve it because im mature and I also am always outside at the mall or at target with friends, and it is unsafe at this point to go out without a phone. I think she thinks im living in the olden days because she makes me walk back from the bus stop every day after school, which is like down 2 roads, and I have nothing at all and its so bad. Im also getting made fun of for it by some big backs in front of me in some classes its soooo annoying and I feel so bad asking to use my friends phones to call my parents or see the camera app, like its so rude and my mom just texts them to ask what im doing its so annoying but I can't just block them from her number because that is how I talk to them. Dont even get me started when someone asks for my number. Its so bad I have to give them my tiktok, and follow them like 8 hours later when I get home and get like 1 hour of screen time. Before, I used to think they secretly couldn't afford it and didn't want to say it, but I usually get any other stuff I want, and my mom just got the iPhone 16 plus today and now I know they just don't want to. I can also afford to get my own with the money I get from holidays and allowance and stuff, but I can't pay for a data plan or anything, and it is soo infuriating because my parents are supposed to help me fit in with kids at school and its so annoying. In social studies class, we have to put our phones in the phone tree on the wall, and mine was the only one that wasn't there and the teacher like shouted in front of the whole class "OH YOU DON'T HAVE A  PHONE?" it was the most embarrassing thing ever and I felt so out of place like I wish I was homeschooled. Also important, I asked around 4th grade for a phone, they said no and I asked again in 5th grade, and my mom said no but she kept on saying "8th grade 8th grade" and she's denying it now and saying in like so many years its so annoying.
by
I have a phone but it got taken away
by
No offense but I came here just to see if anyone agrees with me about not letting children have phones, and anxiety, depression, body dysmorphia, over a phone is one of the most dumbest shits ive ever seen, this generation has become the most laziest people, Ive always wanted more resources to learn more and it's sad to see that many of you now have the crazy amount of resources to learn more, but you choose to text your friend, what a waste.
by

No offense but I came here just to see if anyone agrees with me about not letting children have phones, and anxiety, depression, body dysmorphia, over a phone is one of the most dumbest shits ive ever seen, this generation has become the most laziest people, Ive always wanted more resources to learn more and it's sad to see that many of you now have the crazy amount of resources to learn more, but you choose to text your friend, what a waste.

  by 

OMG SAME I AM 11 I GAVE MY MOM REASONS LIKE NUM 1 I AM GOING TO MIDDLE SCHOOL ITS MY GRAD I SAID I AM A GOOD GIRL AND BARLEY GET IN TROUBLE SHE SAID THATS TURE!!!!! I ASKED HER WHY AND I GOT NO RESPONSE!!! I CLEAN I HAVE ALSOME GRADES AND GUESS WHAT ALL THAT WORK FOR A "No I'll get you one when I get you one" ITS SO FLIPPING ANNOYING AND SHE HAD ONE AT MY AGE BECAUSE GRANDMA TOLD ME!!!!!! I STILL NEED A REASONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
With that spelling you'll never get a phone, and I feel like your lying about the grades.
by
True, My brother is 13 and almost all his friend have phones and I'm 10 and all my friends either have and iPhone, apple watch, or iPad, and then my friend is talking about how they are going to get all this Apple stuff for Christmas (for those of you who celebrate it), it's so annoying. But at least I can use my school computer and I kinda have a tablet, cause no one else in my family uses it, and my dad just randomly got, and no one used it. Literally. I am the only one who uses it, but I don't know the password. Have a good day.
by
Responding to "GirlyGirl<3 :

Yeah! And It's so frustrating cause I cant talk to them about when they got a phone, Becuase they didn't get a real phone until after college.
ago by (380 points)
same here!  i'm in 7th grade and i hate not having one! i need one and i'm tired of having to use my friends phone all the time. i want an iphone to fit in and just because i dont want to the the only kid with an android. i like android a lot and iphones but i just want to fit in for the sake of being able to join groupchats. my parents keep saying i don't need one but it's so boring without one. i mean there are solutions like reading a book (which worked for me) watch videos with your friend (kind of annoying and boring since for you pages or for you, but you and your friend may have different one's) or just using your school chromebook or laptop. you can use the school wifi in the building or play games or something boring or on the bus, most school buses have strong wifi, but it mostly depends.  i always have to use my mom's phone and it's so boring having like 1 hour screentime and not being able to call friends or do anything fun. i dont have any other devices. besides this school computer i'm using to talk to you guys right now, i broke (a kid tbh accidentally) my computer screen at a party and brought it there to fit in because i didnt have a phone and wanted to fit in and not be bored. my parents are african and strict and don't wont to get it fixed. and i'm the first born daughter and life is so hard. i get really jealous when people younger than me get phones while i'm the only one. people always asks if my parents are poor or something. but it isn't the price of the phone, if i was of age my parents would get me any new lastest phone if they like. (i'm not trying to brag- TT but i'm like mid middle class) but they think it's because i'm not being responsible. i'm just really upset that i have go on the bus, wait for a while and take a long walk home all bored while all my friends are on their phones with nice cool parents etc.

20 Answers

+1 vote
by
No offense but you are way too young for a phone. I'm 12 and I have a phone and I deeply regret it. No kid should have a phone until 13, at least a smartphone. Flip phones are much better and maybe explain to them that you feel you need it in emergencies at school, sinse their is a recent uprise in school shootings. Also do not talk back to your parents like that??? That will just make them angrier and lower your chance of even getting a flip phone. I got my phone becasue of medical issues and having to be left at a hospital for up to 3 hours every week but you do not need anything other than a flip phone, offer to only have their numbers and for them to go through it regularly as in once a week.
+1 vote
by

You don't talk back to your parents like that kiddo big-eyes

No offense, but you're a bit too young for a phone anyways.

Also, do you know how much certain phones actually COST?

If you do, okay. But usually they  cost more than 100 dollars.

Also, Hyperbole* :)

I'm 11, and don't have a phone. just a tablet. Hold on till you're older.

by
Same here dude a nine year old is a bit young
by
That's not what they ask, and parent's are NOT the boss of kids. 14th amendment people.
by
I agree but they do control what we spend our money on. For an iPhone it's around 200$ for a newer one it's closer to 1000$
0 votes
by
Dude. I’m 16 and I only got my first phone last year at 14. Don’t rush. It’s a responsibility, it can be dangerous and considering that you just gave out your name, age, gender, and state, I don’t blame your parents at all.
0 votes
by
asherr
0 votes
by
OMG SAME I AM 11 I GAVE MY MOM REASONS LIKE NUM 1 I AM GOING TO MIDDLE SCHOOL ITS MY GRAD I SAID I AM A GOOD GIRL AND BARLEY GET IN TROUBLE SHE SAID THATS TURE!!!!! I ASKED HER WHY AND I GOT NO RESPONSE!!! I CLEAN I HAVE ALSOME GRADES AND GUESS WHAT ALL THAT WORK FOR A "No I'll get you one when I get you one" ITS SO FLIPPING ANNOYING AND SHE HAD ONE AT MY AGE BECAUSE GRANDMA TOLD ME!!!!!! I STILL NEED A REASONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
by (6.3k points)
Maybe she did have one but I didn't get a phone till I was 12 and even then it was only a broken one of my mums. I had to save up for 3 months to be able to get a phone I can use properly.

Girl online going offline
by

YES YES YES!!!!! i am 13 years old and all i have is an apple watch!! she said i can't get a phone until HIGHSCHOOL!!!! i cannot handle this anymore bc kids make fun of me, and i just can't fit in bc of my stupid mother. don't even get me started on trying to get any apps or social media, my flipping mom won't ever let me until i move out. all my other friends have every social media platform you could ever dream of, and I'm stuck as an insecure teen, all because of my parents!! it's supposed to be the other way around, they should make me feel confident instead of self conscious. i don't know HOW i'm gonna survive the rest of my middle school and high school years.

by
im with you, i feel the same way. I'm 14 and going into hs but wont get one until who knows when. I've been begging my parents for forever too
by
bro im 15 almost 16 and my parents said I wont get one till i graduate :( I get good grades,i listen to everything they say.I just want to fit in bro and it so embarassing when my friends ask me "where is your phone"? And its so akward when everyones on their phone and ur sitting there like what do i do.. It geuinly makes me upset bc I stay out of trouble and I need it for emergencies,school related stuff,and contact with my friends especially my relationship with my distance bestfriend for 8yrs that I barley get to talk to now

 why are my parents like this ? :(
ago by
REALLLL I'm 15 and my older sister got her phone at 14. Me and my twin still don't have one. Its SO awkward when ur in a room with ur friends and they're all on their phones and you have no clue what to do.
+1 vote
by (46.1k points)
I don't have a phone i only get one until I'm twelve ur parents seem well ummmmm how do I put it oh yeah RUDE.
0 votes
by (63.1k points)
Yeah, um, so…. I’m ALMOST 12 AND I STILL DONT HAVE A PHONE so I hope u feel better
by
i'm in 9th grade and don't have a phone you guys don't need phones in 5th grade
by (63.1k points)
Um, I’m in 6th
by
same
by
Uhh, I'm literally 15 and I don't have one
0 votes
by
Try sneaking to get a phone and hide it in your shed. If you can keep clean like if you get a trash bag when your parents are asleep
0 votes
by (104k points)

Ask your parents to get you a Pinwheel Phone.

0 votes
by
Parents, always dont want to buy you stuff and it sucks!

Related questions

+3 votes
3 answers 119 views
+3 votes
4 answers 475 views
+1 vote
2 answers 144 views
+11 votes
2 answers 163 views
+3 votes
1 answer 634 views
+11 votes
1 answer 286 views
+7 votes
3 answers 312 views
+8 votes
4 answers 304 views
+9 votes
3 answers 1.6k views

Recent Badges

Notable Question
Asked question received 50 views
- -Minecraftnerd- -
Great Question
Question received +8 upvote
- Booker12 -
Great Question
Question received +8 upvote
- Booker12 -
Great Question
Question received +8 upvote
- Booker12 -
Great Question
Question received +8 upvote
- Booker12 -
...