Both of them sound very kind. But 1 if your younger than 17 i recommend You shouldn't have a boy friend right now. This is beaches it will ruin your friendship. You will date have fun together then someone decides to quit And decided to quit hanging out. Just focus on school, God, and just have fun with both of them. 2 if you are at the age of dating. You should go for the one who loves God and helps you. If they are rude to you, leave asap. It's A small thing now but will prob grow bigger during your relationship.
Hope this helped!